My husband will tell you he doesn’t like dessert, but you do not want to come between him and his key lime pie. On our tour of Brooklyn we stopped in at Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie and D’s 4″ tart was gone before Burke could even exit the shop.If you can’t get to Key West, this shop (on a pier in Red Hook) is an easy way to get that kooky island vibe, without leaving NYC.